Researchers at the Lister Hill Center for Health Policy at the University of Alabama at Birmingham examined state medical malpractice reform legislation from 1975 to 2004 to evaluate the effects of:
- Malpractice reforms on physician malpractice insurance premiums.
- General economic conditions on malpractice insurance premiums.
- Malpractice reforms on employer-sponsored health insurance premiums.
This project was part of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) national program Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization (HCFO).
- In states that introduced caps on noneconomic damages (i.e., compensation for physical pain, mental distress or other nonmonetary losses) malpractice insurance premiums decreased for:
- Internal medicine by 17.3 percent.
- General surgery by 20.7 percent.
- Obstetrics/gynecology by 25.5 percent.
- If a cap of $250,000 on noneconomic damages were introduced in all states that did not have a cap as of 2005 (13 states and the District of Columbia) and reduced to $250,000 in states that had higher caps, there could be an annual savings of $1.4 billion, or 8 percent of total malpractice premium costs.
- Malpractice premiums vary, in part, on the performance of investments made by insurance companies. When investment returns were higher for stocks in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, growth in malpractice insurance premiums was reduced.
- Implementation of "statutes of repose," which establish an absolute time period in which to file a malpractice suit, have some effect on reducing growth in malpractice premiums.
- The growing empirical literature has now established that damage caps have reduced medical malpractice premiums, but the evidence with respect to defensive medicine and physician location decisions is less clear cut.
- In deciding the constitutionality of malpractice reform statutes, state supreme courts do use the findings of empirical health services research but have difficulty distinguishing strong studies from weaker ones.
- Malpractice reforms over 1991–2004 had no effect on the health insurance premiums paid by employers.
- Of the many types of malpractice reforms, only caps on noneconomic damages have had a meaningful effect on reducing the growth of malpractice premiums.
- Since financial investments by malpractice insurance companies affect premium rates, the state of the economy must be considered when examining a medical malpractice "crisis."
Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization Project Results
Individual project results from the RWJF national program, Changes in Health Care Financing and OrganizationRead the Program Results for Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization
- About this grant
The What's Next Health series features leading thinkers and visionaries. Stanford social scientist & innovator BJ Fogg discusses his model f...
We create new opportunities for better health by investing in health where it starts—in our homes, schools, and jobs.
Behavioral economists compete in an Innovation Tournament, devising “nudges” to help make people healthier.
RWJF Nurse Faculty Scholar Jennifer Bellot writes about losing her grandmother to complications from a medical error.
When companies invest in employee wellness, it’s good for health, productivity ... and the bottom line.
Executive Nurse Fellow Jerry Mansfield explains why the University Hospital and the Richard M. Ross Heart Hospital do not have a BSN-only hi...
As smartphone technology becomes ever more ubiquitous and the dangers of tobacco become ever more apparent, it’s not surprising that there a...
Helping us understand what’s driving high health care costs is why we need more transparency in the prices, costs and quality of health care...
Developing small community homes as alternatives to nursing homes, this radical, new national model for skilled nursing care returns control...
MTV executives are attempting to mollify nurses and nursing allies who are outraged over a salacious new “reality” television show about a g...
Team members, grantees, and guests discuss breakthrough ideas that will allow us to move toward solving challenges in health care.
HealthCare.gov: After Fixes, More Enroll in First Two Days of December than Did in All of October - Boston Adds Rentable Bicycle Helmets to ...