Researchers at the University of Southern Maine examined the feasibility of using physician profiling software systems to rank physician specialists by their "cost efficiency"—that is, the extent to which the actual costs incurred by their patients are greater or less than expected for those patients, on average.
The researchers assessed whether two commercially available software packages could produce consistent rankings for each specialty:
- When the two packages were compared one to the other.
- When the rankings were compared year to year.
This project was part of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) national program Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization (HCFO).
- Agreement between rankings from consecutive years was substantial for cardiology, general surgery and neurology, but less so for primary care specialties such as family practice, internal medicine and gynecology.
- Agreement between rankings using the two software systems was also substantial for cardiology, general surgery and neurology. There was little agreement between rankings for family practice, foot surgery, internal medicine and gynecology.
- If pharmacy claims data are absent, accurate rankings are still feasible for cardiology, general surgery and neurology, but not for family practice.
- With the use of appropriate methodologies, health plans and patients can feel confident of cost-efficiency rankings for specialists such as cardiologists, general surgeons and neurologists.
- Caution is needed when interpreting rankings for others, such as family practitioners, gynecologists, internists and foot surgeons.
- Although cost-efficiency rankings might still be useful for feedback to physicians and for improving practice management, using inaccurate scores to reward or penalize physicians should be avoided.
Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization Project Results
Individual project results from the RWJF national program, Changes in Health Care Financing and OrganizationRead the Program Results for Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization View all
Learn how to improve care transitions and prevent avoidable hospital readmissions, and pick up nursing and medical education con-ed credits.
The RWJF Roadmaps to Health Prize honors outstanding community partnerships which are helping people live healthier lives. The six winners w...
Mildred Dalton Manning, the last surviving member of a group of U.S. Army and Navy nurses taken prisoner in the Philippines at the start of ...
A study finds that 96 percent of nurse practitioners and 76 percent of physicians agreed with IOM report recommendation that “nurse practiti...
The strange pull of this series is its humanity, not its horrors.
The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation is working to increase awareness and understanding of the impact of ACEs and the need to develop effectiv...
While the need to address disparities in care is well known, few strategies for reducing disparities have been studied systematically.
A national conversation highlighting efforts to improve care transitions, reduce avoidable hospital readmissions, and lift overall quality o...
Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas examines the ways that the gambling industry has designed gambling machines that encourag...
Playworks improving the health and well-being of children through safe, meaningful play
Team members, grantees, and guests discuss breakthrough ideas that will allow us to move toward solving challenges in health care.
What's Next Health: Conversations with Pioneers features leading thinkers and visionaries helping us explore ideas and trends important to t...