Publication Guidelines for Quality Improvement in Health Care

Evolution of the SQUIRE Project

By: Davidoff F, Batalden P, Stevens D, Ogrinc G and Mooney S

In: Quality and Safety in Healthcare (Supplement), 17(1), pp.i3-i9

Publisher: BMJ Publishing Group LTD

Published: October 2008

Get full text or downloads

  • Publication Guidelines for Quality Improvement in Health Care

Quality improvement efforts in health care are often poorly reported, or not at all. This article traces the evolution of report-writing guidelines that address issues inherent in health care improvement work. The guidelines are intended to help authors produce more usable and consistent manuscripts and encourage more improvement studies to be published.

In 2005, draft guidelines, referred to as SQUIRE (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence), were proposed. Since then, the SQUIRE guidelines have been refined through a consensus process which included gathering formal and informal feedback; "road testing" by journal editors and authors; a literature review; a two-day meeting of editors and scholars who critically analyzed the guidelines and their future use; and finally, a three-cycle Delphi process of final revisions, culminating in 50 participants being asked whether they would endorse the resulting consensus version.

Key elements that distinguish the final SQUIRE 19-item checklist from the draft guidelines include:

  • Distinguishing clearly between the improvements themselves and the evaluation of whether and why or why not the improvements work;
  • Highlighting the unique dimensions of the improvement process, such as its social nature, focus on changing performance, complexity, etc.;
  • Detailing the elements of study design that assess whether efforts to improve care worked and why they did or did not work; and
  • Explicitly addressing ethical issues inherent in studying how to improve health care.

The SQUIRE Web site, www.squire-statement.org,  provides numerous tools to help authors write complete, accurate and transparent articles, including "Explanation and Elaboration" pages on each of the 19 items. The site also provides a focus for continued refinement of the SQUIRE guidelines. The authors support efforts to measure the impact of SQUIRE and its specific elements on the quality of published information on health care improvement efforts.

Tags:

Share:
Share

Listed below is one grant that supported this project.

Grant Awarded to Amount
Developing publication guidelines for quality improvement Dartmouth Medical School Center for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences (Hanover, NH)
ID#: 58073
Paul B. Batalden, M.D.
603-650-6513
Paul.B.Batalden@Dartmouth.edu
Actual award: $299,992
December 2006 to November 2009

RWJF may have supported this project with other grants that are not listed.

Close

The SQUIRE (Standards for Quality Improvement Reporting Excellence) Guidelines for Quality Improvement Reporting

By:
Ogrinc G, Mooney SE, Estrada C, Foster T, Goldmann D, Hall LW, Huizinga MM, Liu SK, Mills P, Neily J, Nelson W, Pronovost PJ, Rubenstein LV, Speroff T, Splaine M, Thomson R, Tomolo AM and Watts B

Publication date:
October 2008

Summary:
The SQUIRE guidelines are a checklist to guide authors of health care improvement studies in writing more usable and consistent reports. This Explanation and Elaboration document provides exemplary examples, plus commentary, of how to address each SQUIRE...

More on Quality/Equality

View resources and information on health care quality.

Evaluations
As defined by the American Evaluation Association, evaluation involves assessing the strengths and weaknesses of programs, policies, personnel, products and organizations to improve their effectiveness. RWJF evaluates programs, major initiatives, policies and, at times, products.

Evaluation tools
Helpful guides detailing the RWJF approach to project or program evaluations.

My presentation builder (beta)

You have not collected any slides or slideshows for your presentation. Learn more about the presentation builder and search for slides on our Web site.